“I have never wished a man dead, but I have read some obituaries with pleasure.”
There is a lot of debate about the origin of this quote and variations of it. Most agree it has a Mark Twain flavor. Regardless, there is no debate about the sentiment I had when I learned of ousted Egyptian dictator Hosni Mubarak’s death this week. At 91, Mubarak finally tested positive for mortality. Islamic tradition asks us to speak well of the dead, but Im planning on writing a piece longer than a few words!
Like all Egyptian military dictators before him, Mubarak came from a humble background join the military academy, then climb the political pyramid to dictatorship. He was born in a village in Monufiya called Kafr al-Meselha, on May 4, 1928. His father, Ibrahim Mubarak, was a courthouse janitor and his mother, Naeema, was a traditional woman, an illiterate housewife.
However, Mubarak ruled Egypt for 30 years; he was called modern Egypt’s Pharaoh. His legacy is a mixed bag, to say the least. In Egypt, the reaction of Mubarak long awaited death, dividing the nation between a sense of relieve and closure, to mourning and nostalgia for those who still stuck in the past look at Mubarak as a father figure we should forgive. He became an accidental leader of Egypt by being in the right place at the right time, sitting next to another military dictator, then-president Anwar Sadat, when Sadat was assassinated during a military parade. Mubarak then was appointed to run Egypt, where proximity is a political virtue. During his 30-year tenure, Mubarak changed the course of Egypt for the worse, taking it from a country leading the Arab world economically and politically to a country that is irrelevant historically and strategically. His regime, fraught with corruption and cronyism, resulted in destroying Egyptian economy, education and culture. Turning Egypt’s economy to his businessmen loyalists with their neoliberalism criminal ideology , Egyptian economy was controlled by world bank and IMF.
Israel became Egypt’s friend and partner in “peace” and Egypt got billions for it. Palestine became Egypt’s enemy. Mubarak sent troops to help Bush invade Iraq and opened prisons for his own opposition. He used Islamists as a bogeyman card to scare the West and get the support he needed, including looking the other way when it came to human rights violations. as Mada Masr reported “…. Mubarak banked largely on the security apparatus as represented by the Interior Ministry and specifically, the State Security Investigation Service. The police force is said to have increased to over a million personnel by 2002, from a mere 150,000 in the 1970s.” … Scholar Hazem Kandil put the ratio of security men to citizens in Mubarak’s Egypt at 25 security men to every 1,000 citizens.”
Mubarak realized that he couldn’t live forever and started grooming his son Gamal to take the helm after him. But the military was alerted and used the Jan. 25 popular “Arab Spring” revolt to oust the dictator.
He was accused of killing protesters and of corruption, and was put on trial in a kangaroo court and sentenced to three years in prison. But he never spent a day in jail. During the trial, he used a Harvey Weinstein-like strategy, a hospital bed instead of a walker. He divided his time between his luxury residence and a luxury hospital.
The military dictator who ruled Egypt for 30 years, stole billions and was never elected will get a honorary military funeral. This is even against the constitution, to have an honorary military funeral for a felon.
This kind treatment never extended to former President Mohammed Morsi. The first civilian elected president was toppled by a military coup, kidnapped and spent six years in prison, in solitary confinement, and never stood a chance in his trial. He was denied medical treatment, legale presentation, In his trial, Morsi has been mistreated and demonized, “i’m surrounded by glass mirrors, I cant see, I don’t know where Im right now and who is talking to me’ he complained, as BBC reported, “Morsi collapsed moments after addressing the court in Cairo … …. He spoke for some five minutes from a soundproof glass cage which officials said was designed to prevent him from disrupting proceedings. Morsi was pronounced dead in hospital at 16:50 local time (14:50 GMT) … .”. Morsi never got a proper burial, or an honorary military funeral or national day of mourning. In less than 24 hours — in secrecy and without a medical report — he was buried in a military cemetery. Not even his wife was allowed to see him.
Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, the dictator who toppled Morsi, is forcing Egypt to mourn Mubarak for three national days. It’s like a rapist putting on a huge wedding to cover up his crime.
Mubarak may have died, but his legacy is still alive.
Ahmed Tharwat, host and producer of the local Arab American TV show “BelAhdan with Ahmed,” writes for local and international publications. He blogs at Notes From America: www.Ahmediatv.com. Follow him on Twitter: @ahmediaTV.